Cost of Saving
Steps, screening and fees

What does each step cost, and what does it catch?

An interview round, a screening test, a sign-up form, a fee, a compliance check, a sign-off. Each is there to do a job. Each also takes time and money, and screens out some of the people it was not meant for. Use this to find the number of steps that does the job, and no more.

Or start with an empty form

The process
rounds
people
%
days
Scheduling, the interviews, the debrief.
What a round costs you
people
hours
Preparing, the interview, the write-up, the debrief.
$
$
The work not being done. A week of the role's pay is the least it can be.
Candidates with other offers
% a week
$
The gap to your second choice, or starting the search again.
hours
Preparing, travelling, the interview, any set task.
What a round catches
%
$
Pay until it is clear, the search repeated, the work redone.
%
Your estimate. The answer shows how high it would need to be.

The cost of each round

    Candidate experience

      Candidate experience does not show in the accounts, and it affects who accepts an offer.

      Show the working

      Every step, every part

      The formulas are B1 to B3 on the formulas page.

      What interview rounds are for

      A hire that does not work out is expensive for the employer and worse for the person hired. Interview rounds exist to make that less likely, and the first ones usually do.

      Each round after that has less left to catch, because the earlier rounds already caught most of it. Its costs do not shrink the same way. The seat stays empty for another week, and the candidates who have other offers are the ones most able to stop waiting.

      So the useful question is not whether to interview carefully. It is which round stops paying for itself, on your own figures.

      What this cannot tell you

      • How much of the remaining risk a round really catches. That is your estimate, and it is the figure the answer turns on. The page shows how high it would need to be.
      • How fast your candidates receive other offers. It differs by role, by market and by season.
      • Rounds that do different jobs. A work sample and a fourth conversation are not the same kind of round, and this treats every round alike.
      • Roles where a mistake is costly enough that every round pays. Put that cost in and the page will say so.
      • Anything about one person. It weighs a process, not a candidate.

      Every barrier on this page

      Hiring: how many steps, and which ones

      • How many interview rounds?Five interview rounds a week apart for a role paying about $104,000. Eight candidates start and half go on each time. The question is which round stops adding more than it costs. Worked example
      • Should the role require a degree?A role that 400 people apply to each month, 30% of whom could not do the job. A degree requirement screens out 60% of those, and 45% of the people who could. A capable applicant costs about $350 to find again; one who could not do the job costs about $150 to screen out at interview instead. Worked example
      • How many years of experience to ask for?Five years of experience asked for, with 300 applicants a month. A quarter could not do the job. The requirement screens out half of those, and 35% of the people who could. Worked example
      • How long should the application be?A five-page application that 600 people start each month. Each page takes about 12 minutes, and 12% of capable applicants stop at each page. Worked example
      • A take-home assignmentA five-hour assignment set for 40 shortlisted candidates a month. A quarter of the capable ones decline it. It screens out 70% of the others, each of whom would otherwise take up an interview. Worked example
      • A general aptitude testA 90-minute general test for 120 candidates a month. On these figures it screens out capable and less suitable candidates at a similar rate. Compare it with the work-sample test beside it: the same time and the same candidates, a different test. Worked example
      • A work-sample testThe same 90 minutes and the same 120 candidates, spent on a task taken from the real work. It screens out most of those who could not do the job and few of those who could. On these figures it pays for itself. Worked example
      • A licence or certificate checkA licence check for a role where an unqualified hire is costly. 200 applicants a month, one in ten without a valid licence. On these figures the check pays for itself many times over. Worked example

      Customers: sign-up, checkout and fees

      • A sign-up formA four-step sign-up. 2,000 people start it each month and 15% are fake or spam accounts. Worked example
      • An account required before buyingShoppers must create an account before they can buy. 3,000 reach the checkout each month, and one in five honest shoppers leaves instead. Worked example
      • Checks at a checkoutTwo checks before an order goes through. 5,000 orders a month, 2% of them fraudulent. On these figures both checks pay for themselves. Worked example
      • A minimum orderA minimum order size. A quarter of 2,000 monthly orders are too small to cover the cost of filling them. The minimum stops most of those and puts off some ordinary customers. On these figures it pays, narrowly. Worked example
      • A membership feeA $5 a month membership before anyone can buy. 4,000 shoppers a month would otherwise buy, each worth about $25. Four in ten decline to join. Worked example
      • A convenience fee at checkoutA $3 fee added at the last step of 3,000 orders a month, each worth about $22. Nine in a hundred customers leave when they see it. On these figures it pays, with little room to spare. Worked example
      • A paywallA paywall at $8 a month in front of 20,000 readers, each worth about 25 cents a month in advertising. Four in a hundred subscribe. On these figures it pays for itself. Worked example
      • Compliance checks for new customersThree identity and compliance steps for 800 new customers a month. Two in a hundred should not be taken on, and each of those would cost about $5,000. Each step takes a customer 20 minutes and loses 9% of the legitimate ones. Where the law requires a check, the question is how many steps it takes, not whether to have it. Worked example
      • A deposit or credit checkA deposit or credit check before service starts. 500 new customers a month, one in ten of whom would not pay. On these figures it pays for itself. Worked example

      Inside the business: approvals

      • Sign-offs on a requestFour sign-offs before a purchase request is approved. 60 requests a month, one in ten a poor use of money. Each sign-off takes the person asking about half an hour. Worked example

      Where to go next

      Free for anyone to use: no ads, no cookies, no sign-in and no personal data needed. Personal portfolio / skills demonstration: not a commercial product.
      For potential employers and recruiters: see my online portfolio at butterflyfx.us for how it was made and the technologies and skills behind it.