The check-up was tried on real history: public company filings, and US manufacturing industries. Part of it held, and part of it did not. Both are here.
On a phone, swipe the tables sideways to see every column.
18,791 company years from 3,052 companies, 2011 to 2023, from SEC filings. Income is revenue, running costs are selling, general and admin, and direct costs are cost of revenue. Each group is compared with balanced companies in the same year with similar revenue change, margin and size. Figures are points more (+) or less (-) often than those companies, with the range the result could reasonably fall in.
| Position | Years | Revenue falls next year | Revenue falls 2 years out | Operating loss next year | Held? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Running costs starved; income and direct costs ahead | 2,161 | +8.0 (5.2 to 10.8) | +12.6 (8.9 to 15.4) | +5.4 (3.0 to 7.5) | Yes |
| Both costs starved; income ahead | 1,274 | +7.6 (0.7 to 13.4) | +15.1 (9.2 to 19.5) | +8.8 (5.6 to 12.6) | Yes |
| Direct costs starved; income and running costs ahead | 532 | +3.6 (-2.8 to 9.2) | +5.4 (-1.3 to 10.6) | +9.6 (5.4 to 14.9) | Profit only |
| Income and running costs starved; direct costs ahead | 1,488 | -0.6 (-5.7 to 3.6) | +3.9 (-1.4 to 7.5) | +10.2 (6.9 to 14.0) | Profit only |
| Income and direct costs starved; running costs ahead | 3,463 | -4.2 (-8.4 to -1.2) | -4.9 (-8.0 to -1.0) | +5.9 (3.3 to 8.7) | Revenue better, profit worse |
| Income starved; both costs ahead | 474 | -10.6 (-18.2 to -3.3) | -13.7 (-21.4 to -5.9) | -1.8 (-9.3 to 5.5) | No, the opposite |
What counted as holding was set before the test ran: revenue falling more often, clearly above zero, in both 2011 to 2016 and 2017 to 2023. The raw rates of the seven positions had already been seen by then, though the rules did not change.
21,359 industry years from 364 industries, 1959 to 2017, from the NBER-CES database. Input is materials, work is production hours, output is shipments, with price changes taken out. Each group is compared with balanced industries in the same year with similar output change and size. The claim to test and what would count were set before any result was seen.
| Position | Years | Output falls next year | Output falls 2 years out | Held? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Work starved; input and output ahead (the claim tested) | 1,344 | +4.5 (1.3 to 7.1) | +6.6 (3.7 to 9.8) | Yes |
| Input and work starved; output ahead | 745 | +7.7 (3.5 to 11.6) | +5.2 (1.6 to 9.8) | Yes |
| Work and output starved; input ahead | 1,028 | +1.8 (-1.0 to 4.9) | +1.6 (-2.0 to 4.7) | No clear change |
| Input starved; work and output ahead | 418 | +1.7 (-3.2 to 6.4) | +1.8 (-3.1 to 6.3) | No clear change |
| Input and output starved; work ahead | 790 | -0.3 (-3.9 to 3.0) | +0.4 (-3.2 to 4.4) | No clear change |
| Output starved; input and work ahead | 175 | -8.6 (-16.1 to -1.3) | -7.1 (-15.3 to 0.4) | No, the opposite |
Both groups that held did so in both 1959 to 1988 and 1989 to 2017. Fewer hours can also mean better tools rather than too little work, and these figures cannot tell the two apart.
| Reading (public companies) | Years | Revenue fell next year | Revenue grew next year | Overhead share up 10% or more | Debt ahead of revenue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stable | 7,098 | 20.4% | 58.1% | 13.9% | 23.0% |
| Stressed | 3,748 | 28.1% | 57.6% | 29.3% | 28.8% |
| Unstable | 7,945 | 36.2% | 52.1% | 26.5% | 31.3% |
For ranking which companies would see revenue fall, the reading scored 0.593, where 0.5 is a coin toss. That beat "did they lose money this year?" at 0.546 and was about level with "how did revenue change this year?" at 0.601. So it is a modest signal. Its added value is saying which part is being starved, not out-predicting a simple trend.
Free for anyone to use: no ads, no cookies, no sign-in and no personal data needed. Personal portfolio / skills demonstration: not a commercial product.
For potential employers and recruiters: see my online portfolio at butterflyfx.us for how it was made and the technologies and skills behind it.