Cost of Saving
Two bottom lines

On-site, hybrid or work from home?

Where the work happens changes two bottom lines at once: the business's, and each person's. Put in your team and see both.

This page does not recommend an arrangement. The right one depends on the work, the people and the place, and the same sums give different answers for different teams. The three examples below each come out a different way.

Weighing a cut or a gain instead? Use the win or lose calculator.

Before the sums: can the work be done remotely?

The first question is not where people should work. It is where the work can be done. These four questions come before any figure. They change nothing in the sums below; they tell you what to check when you enter yours.

How much of this team's work can be done away from the site?
Is the work done face to face with customers or clients?
When people are in the office, who do they work with?
Would a day in the office be spent differently from a day at home?
Three different teams, three different answers

The team

people
$
$
Rent, power, cleaning, services.
$
Hiring, training, the slow first months.
$
Leave empty to use their pay, the least it can be worth.
people
Used with the weeks a new person takes to get up to speed.
$
Fuel or fares, parking, lunch out.
hours
There and back.
$
Heating, power, internet.
$
Optional. Puts a figure on the hours spent travelling.

On-site

Everyone in, every working day.

days
%
Lower when desks are shared.
$
Equipment, allowance.
% a year
Write 5 if 5% more leave, -3 if 3% fewer.
%
Write -2 for 2% less, 3 for 3% more. Leave at 0 if you do not know.
%
Write 3 for 3% more, -3 for 3% less. Leave at 0 if none.
weeks
$
Travel and rooms for meeting in one place.
Write -2 for 2% less, 3 for 3% more. Leave at 0 if you do not know.

Hybrid

Some days in, some at home.

days
%
Lower when desks are shared.
$
Equipment, allowance.
% a year
Write 5 if 5% more leave, -3 if 3% fewer.
%
Write -2 for 2% less, 3 for 3% more. Leave at 0 if you do not know.
%
Write 3 for 3% more, -3 for 3% less. Leave at 0 if none.
weeks
$
Travel and rooms for meeting in one place.
Write -2 for 2% less, 3 for 3% more. Leave at 0 if you do not know.

Work from home

At home, with an office to visit if at all.

days
%
Lower when desks are shared.
$
Equipment, allowance.
% a year
Write 5 if 5% more leave, -3 if 3% fewer.
%
Write -2 for 2% less, 3 for 3% more. Leave at 0 if you do not know.
%
Write 3 for 3% more, -3 for 3% less. Leave at 0 if none.
weeks
$
Travel and rooms for meeting in one place.
Write -2 for 2% less, 3 for 3% more. Leave at 0 if you do not know.

The business

Yearly cost of the things that differ: desks, home working support, people leaving, output, any difference in pay, getting new people up to speed, and bringing the team together. Pay itself is the same under all three unless you enter a difference.

Each employee

    What each person pays out of their own pocket in a year, and the hours they spend travelling. These are not in the business total, and they are part of what people weigh.

    What each arrangement is weighed for

    These are the points most often raised for each, by the people who favour it and the people who do not. They are considerations, not findings. Which of them apply to your team, and how strongly, is for you to put in the figures above.

    On-site

    Often raised for it

    • New people learn faster beside experienced ones.
    • Questions get answered in passing, without a meeting.
    • Shared equipment, secure systems and physical work are in one place.
    • Home and work stay separate.

    Often raised against it

    • Desks and buildings are a large fixed cost.
    • The commute costs each person money and hours.
    • Hiring is limited to people within reach of the office.

    Hybrid

    Often raised for it

    • Days together for the work that needs them, days apart for the work that does not.
    • Fewer desks when they are shared.
    • Less commuting without losing the office.

    Often raised against it

    • It needs co-ordinating: the days in only help if the right people are in.
    • Shared desks do not suit every kind of work.
    • The office is still paid for on the days it is half empty.

    Work from home

    Often raised for it

    • Little or no office cost.
    • No commute for the people doing the work.
    • Hiring is not limited by distance.
    • Long stretches of uninterrupted time.

    Often raised against it

    • New people can take longer to get up to speed.
    • Working together takes more planning.
    • Equipment, home costs and occasional travel replace some of the saving.
    • Not every home suits working in, and not every job can be done from one.

    The evidence on output and on who leaves is mixed and differs by kind of work. That is why this page supplies no figure for either and asks for yours.

    Show the working

    How this answer was worked out

    What this cannot tell you

    • How an arrangement changes output. That differs from team to team and is argued over. The page takes your figure and shows how far it can be wrong before the answer changes.
    • How many people an arrangement will drive away or draw in. That is your estimate too.
    • Work that can only be done in one place, and what the law or a contract requires.
    • What is not money: how well people work together, how new people learn, and what each person's home allows.

    The formulas are A1 on the formulas page. It assumes a five-day week and 48 working weeks a year. The page has no preferred answer: the three examples each favour a different arrangement.

    Where to go next

    Free for anyone to use: no ads, no cookies, no sign-in and no personal data needed. Personal portfolio / skills demonstration: not a commercial product.
    For potential employers and recruiters: see my online portfolio at butterflyfx.us for how it was made and the technologies and skills behind it.